Tariffs; the Misunderstood and Misused Tax
Tariffs are a tax on consumers and anyone who claims to be on the side of free trade should reject them to stay logically consistent. Other countries don't pay them, whoever imports the tariffed product pays and passes the cost on to the consumer-always. That's why some people are complaining that refunds from illegal tariffs are going to the importers rather than consumers. While it's true that tariffs were the main source of funding at the founding of the USA, it turned out to not be a very steady source because of wars, boycotts and other disruptions of international trade. As time went on, tariffs became an ever smaller portion of federal revenues such that by the first few years of the 20th century, they were no longer the main source. In 1913, the 16th Amendment to the Constitution was ratified, shifting the main source of federal revenue to income taxes with its associated bureaucracy and which I think ought to be structured as per my previous post.
While targeted tariffs may be useful in some circumstances, they are inflationary and unless enacted by Congress subject court challenges and to the whims of whoever happens to be President at the time. If the goal is to bring jobs to the US, it would be far more effective to require that every product and service bought or sold in the US follow US law from exploration and discovery, to extraction, refinement, fabrication, assembly, transport, storage and sale. If the goal is to hurt some other country, why are we even trading with that country? If the goal is to raise revenue, why not just raise taxes outright instead of doing it in an underhanded manner with tariffs? Sure, the user of the tariffed products pays the most but if you want a consumer oriented economic system, it seems to me you would want to keep the price of all products low so most people can afford them (also called "affordability"). Another thing about tariffs is they make financial planning and investment much riskier for businesses if not done in a methodical and logical manner, something definitely not done with recent ones.
In summary, I think income taxes, not tariffs (which are really a tax, anyway), are the best means the federal government has for raising revenues. Raising revenue through income taxes (as I have described in the previous post) is at once more honest, simpler and fairer. Raising $40,000,000,000,000 is no easy task, however, no matter how you do it.....
Comments
Post a Comment